If you’re considering cloth diapers and you’re not sure what brand to pick, it can be a daunting task! I’d like to say we tried several so I could tell you why we picked bumGenius. Unfortunately, that’s not the case. I read a lot of reviews, talked to others who had done cloth diapers, and ultimately, chose bumGenius based on the info I got. My brother and his wife used bumGenius, as did our pediatrician. The reviews I read on Amazon and other parent forums were great. So, we chose bumGenius too.
One of the biggest questions I get is: “What’s the difference between the original pocket style and the all-in-one?” The pocket style has an outer shell with an opening at the back that you stuff inserts into. The all-in-ones are just that. The outer shell and two layer “inserts” are all attached as one unit.
At first, after reading reviews, I was pretty sure we would want to use the pocket style, so that’s what we stocked up on. I had a couple all-in-ones for comparison, but my gut instinct was the pockets would be better. After all, the pocket style allowed you to double- and triple-stuff as needed. That seemed like a no-brainer. Overnight diapering would require more inserts, right? Not necessarily.
While double-stuffing clearly adds more absorbency, it also makes the diaper more bulky and thus harder to get a good, snug fit. What does that mean? That means you are more susceptible to gaps at the legs and waist, and gaps lead to leakage. The pocket style also by its very nature makes the waistband bulkier. And again, more bulk leads to gaps and leakage. Don’t get me wrong – we still use the pocket style, but I now prefer the all-in-ones.
The all-in-ones have one bigger drawback, though. They take quite a bit longer to dry. Keep in mind – cloth diapers have to air dry so you want to plan accordingly and wash with enough time to dry before you’ll run out of diapers. I typically wash when there are three clean diapers left (or right after he goes to bed so they can dry overnight).